Welcome to The Cereal Spot, a delightful café nestled in Buffalo at 547 Elmwood Ave. This unique establishment has quickly become a local favorite, known for its whimsical take on traditional desserts, all with a nostalgic twist that will take you back to your childhood. From lively milkshakes to creative cereals, The Cereal Spot is a haven for both the young and the young at heart.
Imagine a place where the sweet flavors of your favorite childhood cereals come to life in the form of extravagant milkshakes. The menu boasts tantalizing options like the Fruity Pebbles Milkshake, crafted with luscious strawberry cheesecake ice cream, or the Birthday Cake Milkshake, which is as festive as it sounds. Each shake is priced at just US$8.00 and comes beautifully topped with whipped cream, making them not only delectable but also perfect for Instagram-worthy snapshots.
Beyond shakes, you’ll find mouth-watering specialty items like the S’mores Sundae, featuring Graham Slam ice cream and Honeymaid s’mores cereal, all for a reasonable US$10.00. Breakfast meets dessert in an unforgettable way with offerings like the Cap’n Crunch French Toast, which features a scrumptious Crunch Berries crust and is drizzled with maple syrup. At US$11.00, it’s a perfect blend of sweet and savory that you won’t want to miss.
For those with dietary concerns, The Cereal Spot offers delightful surprises as well. There are two flavors of nondairy ice cream and even oat milk available, which has received rave reviews from patrons with dairy allergies. One customer expressed their appreciation for the thoughtful options, ensuring that everyone can indulge in the fun.
With an ambiance packed with cheerful decor and a clean, inviting setup, The Cereal Spot delivers more than just great food; it promises an experience. Customers rave about the engaging atmosphere and the happiness it brings to families. From Mason jar sundaes to inventive cereal tacos, every dish offers a chance to let your imagination run wild. The vibrant selection of over a dozen cereals invites creativity and allows guests to concoct their dream dessert.
Whether you’re heading in for an early-morning treat or a late-night indulgence, The Cereal Spot is a must-visit for anyone with a sweet tooth. So gather your friends or bring your family; a delicious adventure awaits!
We’d love to hear from you! Your email address will remain private. Required fields are marked *
Terrie
01/08/2025
The Cereal Spot is such a unique place! I was worried going there, as my husband had a dairy allergy. They offer two flavors of nondairy ice cream and they even had oatmilk (which is my husband’s favorite and most places do not offer this). They have so many cereal flavors as well and such unique combinations! We can’t wait to go back again!
Troy D
27/07/2025
One of the most unique ice cream shops in Buffalo. Great selection of cereals and several ice cream flavors, let your imagination go wild. Anyone with a sweet-tooth can come in early morning or right before bed. Your children will have fun picking all the toppings for the creation. My favorite desert was the Mason jar sundae !
Jennifer R
16/07/2025
What a unique place! Took my kids here and we were blown away with the variety of cereals to choose from. We tried a Mason jar sundae, a milkshake and even a taco. Everyone left happy and sugared up! The store is clean, the service was outstanding, and the decor is fun! This is a must go!
Sanchit Goel
02/07/2025
A very unique & interesting place. Had the Apple Pie milkshake, it was rich, thick and could taste apple jacks cereal all the way, would recommend. The cereal taco is a very interesting take on dessert.
Daviyion Johnson
25/06/2025
Didn't actually get a bowl cereal when I went, but my friend had the Fruity Pebbles taco and it looked and tasted good (she let me try some). I ordered a slice of cake. It was a Cinnamon Toast crunch churros cake ($5) and it was yummy. I should have let it warm up a bit before eating it as it was in the cooler, but it was still good nonetheless. The place has a cool aesthetic and that alone is worth popping in to check out.
Keith Birchenough
10/06/2025
This is a great idea!!! So so many types of cereal...stuff that brought back memories and stuff I'd neither seen nor heard of!!! Very cool!!! Service was great and my daughter and the neighborhood girls loved every last bite!!! I had the mini pancakes combined with Captain Crunch, so good. I would recommend this place to anyone!!! I will definitely be back!!!
Amber Ferger
02/06/2025
What a unique place! Neat atmosphere inside and a wide selection of cereal to choose from. We got the ice cream tacos which were very tasty, but a little on the pricey side ($6.25 for one). I recommend checking this place out if you want something a little different for a snack!
Iris E.
01/05/2025
This is the most wonderful idea for a shop I have ever seen. Walking in you can expect to be greeted with a big smile and LOTS of options. 100+ kinds of cereal, 20+ kinds of icecream, 20+ types of milk, and 20+ toppings. The cashier describes the basics of what you can get then you can just expand and be creative from that point. Great spot and all age friendly! See you spoon!